Amherst MagazineSkip repeated navigation.
Amherst College  
Site Map
Amherst College > News & Events > Amherst Magazine > Archives > Summer 2004 > A Soldier’s Tale

A Soldier’s Tale

1 | 2 | 3 | Rieckhoff Speaks Out | Other Amherst Grads in Military

Rieckhoff Speaks Out

Paul Rieckhoff made national news again in May 2004, when he delivered the Democrats’ response to the president’s weekly radio address, an outlet normally reserved for politicians. Rieckhoff’s address received wide attention, not only because of his status as a citizen, but also for his strong criticism of the Bush administration’s handling of the war in Iraq. “After all the waiting,” he said, “after all the mistakes we had experienced firsthand over in Iraq, after another year of a policy that was not making the situation any better for our friends who are still there, [the president] told us we were staying the course. He told us we were making progress. And he told us that, ‘We’re carrying out a decision that has already been made and will not change.’… My question for President Bush—who led the planning of this war so long ago—is this: When will you take responsibility for the decisions you’ve made in Iraq and realize that something is wrong with the way things are going?”

In an interview after his radio address, Rieckhoff said he was speaking as a private citizen who wanted to convey the mixed situation in Iraq. Nonetheless, Rieckhoff’s remarks generated a great deal of media attention, as well as some strong criticism. The day after Rieckhoff’s address, Gen. Richard B. Myers, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, told ABC’s “This Week” that Rieckhoff had done a “very political thing.” Although Myers acknowledged many of Rieckhoff’s complaints about equipment, he took exception to the fact that they came from a soldier. “It sounds a little too political for my taste,” the general said. On the same program, Republican Sen. John McCain also criticized what Rieckhoff had done. “I think it’s important for us not to try to involve our men and women who are serving in the military, no matter how strong their views are,” McCain said. “There’s a clear line between civilian and military in America, as far as politics is concerned. I respect and cherish the opinion of all young men and women, but I don’t think it has a place in this presidential campaign.”

Rieckhoff later said that he knew his views would not be welcomed by everyone, but that he felt obligated to speak out.

Next: Other Amherst Grads in Military >>


Online Extra

Complete text of the interviews with Paul Rieckhoff ’98

Transcript of Paul Rieckhoff's Talk at Amherst

Audio excerpts from Rieckhoff's talk at Amherst


Rieckhoff's organization, Operation Truth:

Transcript of the original “60 Minutes” story on Rieckhoff

Memorial pages for Spc. Robert Wise, who was killed in action:

Memorial pages for CSM Eric Cooke, who was killed in action on Christmas Eve:

TAPS (Tragedy Assistance Program for Survivors) supports the families of injured, wounded or killed soldiers:

Pages about Sgt. Dustin Tuller, who lost his legs in combat:

A Trust Fund for Sgt. Tuller’s wife and three children, titled the "Tuller Family Benefit Fund," has been set up through the Bank of America. Contributions can be made at any Bank of America, or at the the following address:

Bank of America
"The Tuller Family Benefit Fund"
c/o Debbie Booth
100 West Garden St 4th Floor
Pensacola, Fl 32501

  E-mail the Editor  
Search Amherst magazine